“How do you say that God puts babies into homes where they’re mistreated or abused?”
The question didn’t come from anger, though there was a deep, aching honesty behind it. A friend brought it to our table after a conversation with someone who doesn’t believe in God at all—someone convinced that this life is all there is, and when you die, you’re simply done. My friend didn’t know how to respond when she was asked, and she was hoping we could help her find the words.
Around the table, the air went completely still. None of us had a ready answer either.
How many times do we walk away from a moment like that and spend the next several hours replaying it in our heads? You sit in the quiet afterward, wishing you had found the right words in the moment, wishing you could have reached across the table with something true and gentle.
When someone asks a question that heavy, the worst thing you can do is offer a quick, polished cliché just to fill the silence. Saying “God has a plan” when someone is talking about an innocent child being hurt doesn’t defend God—it makes Him sound callous, and it makes us sound like we aren’t really listening.
Truthfully, this is a question I have struggled with myself over the years. Even as I walk closer with God and spend more time studying His Word, I still don’t completely understand everything about why suffering is allowed to happen. My mind still runs to the innocent—the defenseless children, even the helpless animals—and my heart aches for them. Understanding more doesn’t erase the grief of seeing something pure get hurt.
Still, sitting with the question afterward helped me sort through what I have come to trust, even when I can’t trace every answer—and what I wish I’d been able to offer my friend in that moment.
The question begins with a painful misunderstanding: that if God exists, He is personally hand-placing children into cruelty as part of His design. But there is a vast difference between what God creates and what broken people choose to do.
God is the author of life, not the author of abuse.
God created human beings with the capacity to choose, and those choices carry consequences. In a fallen world, people can choose selfishness, addiction, cruelty, and unspeakable harm. The devastating reality is that the innocent often suffer because of someone else’s sin. But God’s permission of human choice should never be confused with His approval of what people choose to do.
When adults make destructive choices, the most vulnerable people around them—often their own children—pay the price. That isn’t God’s assignment. It is a violation of His heart.
And God is never standing at a clinical distance while a child hurts. Scripture reminds us in Psalm 34 that the Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit. He isn’t indifferent to suffering; He steps right into the middle of the pain with the ones who are hurting.
If anyone doubts how fiercely God feels about the mistreatment of children, they only have to look at Jesus. When Jesus spoke about little ones in Matthew 18, He didn’t brush past their vulnerability—He warned that anyone who harms a child would be better off with a heavy millstone hung around their neck and dropped into the depths of the sea.
That isn’t a God who shrugs at evil. That is a Savior who is furious at cruelty, who grieves every bruise, and who promises ultimate justice.
Perhaps this is also where our faith must become more than words. If God has such a heart for the little ones, then His people should too. We cannot simply grieve over the mistreatment of children while remaining silent when they need someone to stand up for them. Protecting the vulnerable, speaking for those who cannot speak for themselves, and refusing to turn away from injustice are not separate from our faith. They are expressions of it.
And that is where my friend’s neighbor and I see the world so differently.
If this life really is the whole story—if death is simply the final period at the end of the sentence—then a child who suffers in this world simply loses, and the people who hurt them walk away untouched. There is no scales-balancing, no healing, no restoration.
My faith doesn’t give me every single answer, and it doesn’t stop my heart from hurting for the defenseless. What it gives me is peace in knowing that every person will eventually answer for what they have done on this earth—and that evil does not get the final word.
It holds onto the promise in Revelation 21 that a day is coming when God Himself will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death, mourning, crying, and pain will be no more.
If you ever find yourself frozen at a table, wishing you had the right words for a question too big for the moment, take heart.
You don’t have to defend God like a lawyer, and you don’t have to pretend you understand every reason why evil is allowed to exist for a season.
Sometimes the most honest, Christlike thing you can say first is simply:
“You’re right—it is monstrous, and it breaks my heart too. I don’t believe God wants that for any child, and honestly, the only way I can face a world this broken is believing this life isn’t the end—that God’s mercy is greater than anything we can comprehend, and one day He will make every wrong right.”
Stand on that shared ground first. Let your heart break alongside theirs.
And then, when the moment allows, you can quietly share why you believe God isn’t the cause of the brokenness—He’s the only One compassionate enough to carry the hurt, and strong enough to redeem it.
